The Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works: Conclusion and Implementation

The Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works emerged as works circulated across borders while national copyright protections remained uneven. The International Literary Association, established in Paris in 1878, advocated a multilateral union. It adopted a draft in Berne in 1883, after which the Swiss Federal Council circulated it to governments and convened diplomatic negotiations.

Three diplomatic conferences met in Berne in 1884, 1885, and 1886, chaired by Swiss politician Numa Droz. In 1885 they produced three drafts: a convention, an additional article, and a final protocol. The conference of September 6–9, 1886 turned them into formal instruments. US representative Boyd Winchester's dispatch recorded the meeting in the Swiss Council of States chamber and explained that he lacked plenipotentiary authority to conclude a treaty: the United States took part in discussion but did not sign.

References: [1] [2]

On September 9, 1886, Britain, France, Germany, Belgium, Spain, Italy, Switzerland, Haiti, Liberia, and Tunisia signed the convention, forming a union for the protection of literary and artistic works. Its membership was not exclusively European, and signature did not mean it took effect in each country that day.

Article Twenty-One required an exchange of ratifications in Berne within a year, while Article Twenty provided for entry into force three months after exchange. On September 5, 1887, the nine signatories other than Liberia exchanged ratifications, and the convention entered into force on December 5. Winchester also recorded that Britain extended its participation to colonies and overseas possessions, while Spain reserved its position until ratification. The geographical reach of protection thus also reflected contemporary imperial relationships.

References: [1] [3] [5]

The core of Article Two was that authors from union countries would enjoy in other member countries the rights local law granted domestic authors. National laws and courts implemented protection; the convention did not create a single authority issuing worldwide copyright. For published works, the place of first publication helped determine the country of origin; for simultaneous publication in several countries, the country granting the shorter term was used.

The 1886 text still required compliance with conditions and formalities under the law of the work's country of origin, and protection abroad could not exceed its term there. The later system of protection without formalities therefore cannot be projected wholesale onto this original convention. Article Three also offered a route to protection for publishers of works by authors from nonunion countries when published within the union, showing that publication location and authorial nationality were not always the same test.

References: [1]

The convention listed works including books, pamphlets, plays, music, paintings, sculpture, engravings, and maps. Article Five granted the exclusive right to translate or authorize translation for ten years after publication of the original in a union country. Lawful translations also received protection, but this could not prevent others from translating an original no longer subject to an exclusive translation right.

Protection was not unlimited. The original text allowed authors or publishers to prohibit reproduction of newspaper and periodical articles through an express notice, but excluded political discussion articles, daily news, and miscellaneous news from such prohibitions. Educational and scientific anthologies were left to national laws or special agreements. Separate rules covered dramatic performances, musical performances, and adaptations, while the final protocol excepted the manufacture and sale of mechanical musical instruments. These provisions reflected specific compromises among publishing, performance, and technological interests.

References: [1]

Before signing, Britain passed the International Copyright Act on June 25, 1886. Its preamble expressly stated that without parliamentary authorization, the convention drafted in 1885 could not be implemented in British dominions and the Crown could not become a party. The act permitted Orders in Council to extend domestic-law protection arrangements to relevant foreign countries.

The Order in Council of November 28, 1887 listed the other eight ratifying countries and declared the convention effective within British dominions, granting corresponding protection to qualifying foreign works. Article Nine made the order itself operative on December 6, a date distinct from the convention's international entry into force on December 5. The Western Australian Government Gazette reprinted the order and convention in May 1888, recording transmission of the rules through colonial administration. Publication alone does not establish that remedies were provided for every infringement.

References: [4] [5]

Article Sixteen created an International Bureau under Swiss supervision, with expenses shared by members. The final protocol required it to collect national copyright information, publish a French-language periodical, answer specialist inquiries, help prepare conferences, and issue annual administrative reports. Funding initially used six classes with different contribution units, and an interim annual expenditure ceiling of 60,000 francs. This was a treaty ceiling, not the year's actual expenditure.

The Bureau began publishing the monthly Le Droit d’Auteur in January 1888, establishing a continuing channel for exchanging national laws and related information. The convention also allowed further revision and compatible interstate agreements granting greater protection. The Paris conference of 1896 subsequently amended several provisions. The early achievement of the Berne system was therefore to connect cross-border treatment, domestic implementation, and permanent information exchange, rather than eliminate every copyright difference with a single signature.

References: [1] [2] [3]