The Battle of Midway: Carrier Combat and the Defense of a Base

The Battle of Midway unfolded in the central Pacific in June 1942. Japan sought to seize Midway and draw out and destroy the American carrier force; the United States defended it with both island-based aircraft and a fleet at sea. The first encounters at sea occurred on June 3, the carrier engagements on June 4 decided the main outcome, and pursuit and rescue operations continued for several more days. The damaged Yorktown sank on June 7.

Isoroku Yamamoto commanded Japan's Combined Fleet. Chuichi Nagumo commanded the mobile force, which included the carriers Akagi, Kaga, Soryu, and Hiryu, while landing and supporting forces approached from different directions. Nagumo's battle report shows that the Japanese initially believed no strong American force centered on carriers was nearby. They expected first to suppress the island's aircraft, then deal with the fleet that came to counterattack. That assessment differed crucially from the actual deployments.

References: [1] [3]

Chester Nimitz, commander in chief of the U.S. Pacific Fleet, concentrated the forces available to him in advance. Parker's history of communications intelligence explains how centers in Hawaii, Melbourne, and elsewhere gradually identified the target and timing of the Japanese plan. The connection between Joseph Rochefort and fleet intelligence officer Edwin Layton was particularly important. By late May, intelligence personnel had assessed that Midway would be attacked on June 4. This did not mean they could read every subsequent Japanese message.

Raymond Spruance led Task Force 16, centered on Enterprise and Hornet; Frank Jack Fletcher led Task Force 17, with Yorktown. The latter carrier had just returned damaged from the Coral Sea. Pearl Harbor's shipyard and logistical units made her fit for combat within three days and reequipped her air group. The two forces rendezvoused northeast of Midway on June 2 under Fletcher's command. Turning the intelligence advantage into fighting strength therefore depended on ship repairs, supplies, and timely departures.

References: [2] [4]

On June 3, American patrol aircraft sighted Japanese ships approaching Midway but had not yet located the main carrier force. Early on June 4, patrol aircraft reported a large formation of incoming planes and subsequently sighted Japanese carriers. Radar also provided warning. Available aircraft on the island took off quickly: fighters intercepted the bombers, while attack aircraft headed toward the enemy ships.

Japanese aircraft began bombing at about 6:30 a.m. Power facilities and hangars on Eastern Island and fuel tanks on Sand Island suffered severe damage, but the runways remained usable. American land-based aircraft launched successive attacks but sustained heavy losses and failed to stop the Japanese carriers from continuing their operations. Early battle reports on both sides exaggerated some destruction or hits. Smoke and flames seen by pilots in fast-moving combat cannot simply be counted as confirmed ship sinkings.

References: [1] [2] [3]

After receiving reports of the enemy, the American carriers launched their strike groups, but their routes, search decisions, and arrival times did not fully coincide. Torpedo planes lacked sufficient fighter cover and suffered severe losses to Japanese fighters and antiaircraft fire; some dive-bombers failed to find targets. The battle did not unfold as a strictly coordinated attack in which every aircraft type struck simultaneously according to plan.

Shortly after 10:20 a.m., dive-bombers from Enterprise and Yorktown attacked the Japanese carriers, setting Akagi, Kaga, and Soryu ablaze and putting them out of action. The Japanese report describes fire spreading into Akagi's hangar, accompanied by explosions. With firefighting pumps also unable to function properly, Nagumo had to transfer his command post. The destruction of the three ships involved both bomb hits and internal fires and damage control. It cannot simply be described as all three sinking the instant the bombs struck.

References: [1] [2] [3]

Hiryu, still operational, launched bombing and torpedo attacks in succession, hitting Yorktown in both attacks. After the first, the American crew extinguished fires and restored some power. Further torpedo hits left the ship listing severely, forcing the crew to abandon her. That afternoon, American reconnaissance aircraft located Hiryu, and bombers launched from Enterprise severely damaged her. All four principal Japanese carriers involved in the battle were thus lost, and the plan to seize the island was not carried out.

The fighting did not end when the carriers caught fire. American forces continued searching for and pursuing Japanese ships while organizing towing, pumping, and firefighting efforts to save Yorktown. On June 6, a Japanese submarine attacked the salvage group, sinking the destroyer Hammann, which was alongside the carrier assisting the work, and hitting the carrier again. Yorktown held out until June 7 but still sank, demonstrating the danger faced by salvage personnel even after the battle's outcome was clear.

References: [1] [2] [3]

For Midway's defenders, saving the island did not mean that life and work immediately returned to normal. Damage to the fuel system prevented normal aircraft refueling. Personnel had to carry fuel drums and transfer their contents with hand pumps. The official combat narrative records that on the night of June 4, Marine aviation personnel, Patrol Squadron 44, and raider troops worked through the night to make the following day's sorties possible.

Island personnel also had to treat the wounded, receive returning aircraft, and prepare for a possible landing. The Japanese withdrawal ultimately left the United States in control of this military outpost west of Hawaii. Meanwhile, damage to power, fuel, and aviation facilities left a burden of repairs. The fortunes of the carriers at sea and the labor of ordinary service personnel keeping the small island's base operating were different parts of the same battle.

References: [1] [2]

In his report, Nimitz proposed specific improvements: more joint training between aircraft and the fleet, clearer position and target reports, and better shipborne radar, fighter direction, and carrier fire prevention. The report also noted that placing Midway's aircraft and nearby submarines under a common communications arrangement could reduce the number of stages through which intelligence had to pass. These lessons translated battlefield performance into questions of organization and equipment, rather than attributing it solely to one commander.

Nagumo's conclusions likewise called for stronger search operations, flexible concentration and dispersal of forces, and faster launches after enemy ships were discovered. Midway changed the balance of carrier strength and frustrated Japan's plans to advance in the area. Yet American forces also lost ships, aircraft, and personnel: victory did not mean the Pacific War was over. Comparing the two sides' reports makes the relationships among prior assessments, information transmission, aviation operations, and emergency repairs easier to understand.

References: [2] [3]